Chapter 4: Weighing the Ethical Issues


  • Appreciate the role of ethics in technical communication
    • Things can be technically accurate but also misleading
    • Legal does not always mean ethical
  • Identify workplace pressures that lead to unethical communication
    • People exaggerate their credentials or experience
    • People negotiate huge sales by downplaying the faults with a product
    • Managers write strong recommendations for friends over someone more qualified
    • Workers may
      • Yield to social pressure
      • Mistake groupthink for teamwork
  • Recognize common workplace examples of hiding the truth
    • Suppressing knowledge the public needs
      • Biotech industries don't want genetically modified ingredients identified
      • Science journals won't publish studies on chlorine and fluoride in drinking water causing cancer
      • Airlines don't call attention to near misses and safety lapses
    • Hiding conflicts of interest
      • Research-related financial ties
      • Drug review pieces with financial links to drug companies
    • Exaggerating claims about technology
    • Falsifying or fabricating data
    • Using visual images that conceal the truth
    • Stealing or divulging proprietary information
    • Misusing electronic information
      • plagiarism of electronic sources
      • copying digital files
      • failing to protect personal information of website visitors
      • selling prescription medications online 
      • offering inaccurate medical advice
    • Withholding information people need for their jobs
    • Exploiting cultural differences
  • Use critical thinking to help solve ethical dilemmas
    • How can I know the best action?
    • What are my obligations, and to whom?
      • Consider obligations to yourself, clients, your company, coworkers, your community, and society
    • What values or ideals do I want to represent?
    • What will happen if I make this decision?
    • Anticipate some hard choices
      • What do I report and to whom?
      • How much should I reveal or conceal?
      • How do I say what I have to say?
      • Do I have any misplaced obligations that could be causing harm to others?
  • Differentiate between ethical practices and legal guidelines
    • Legal doesn't necessarily mean ethical
    • Never depend solely on legal guidelines
      • Misleading Statements
        • Promises you know you can't keep
        • Assurances you haven't verified
        • Credentials you don't have
        • Inflated claims about your commitment
    • Laws
      • against deception
      • against libel
      • protecting employee privacy
      • copyright
      • against software theft
      • against electronic theft
      • against stealing or revealing trade secrets
      • against deceptive or fraudulent advertising
      • liability
  • Avoid plagiarism- either intentional or unintentional
    • Give credit to those who have done the work
    • Between paraphrasing and entire paragraphs- always cite your sources
  • Determine when and how to report ethical violations on the job
    • Make sure you get your facts straight
    • See if the company has an ombudsman to help employees file complaints
    • Check hotlines for advice on ethics problems and reporting misconduct
    • Determine if there is a formal code for personal/ organizational behavior
    • No employer will tolerate a public statement that makes the company look bad
    • Some states protect employees who blow the whistle- you should know the potential consequences for whistle-blowing

No comments:

Post a Comment